BANNER COMPETITION!

[Erkendorn]

CAEWYN's BANNER:
Eru 9.5/10. Excellent work there! I like it, but it just doesnt seem to get the full mark
Estel 8/10.
Goldie 10/10
Seles 8/10 Nice, but the background was a little too dark for me to appreciate, I liked the colours though!

35.5/40

AISIL's BANNER:
Eru 7/10 It is quite good, like the back component, but the size and font does not appeal very well. Good work though!
Estel 7/10
Goldie 8/10
Seles 7/10 Aw you're going to have to work on the font a bit, the red doesn't really suit the background that you have selected. Picture quality's a little off too, but good effort!

29/40

LAU's BANNER:
Eru 8.5/10 Very nice! I like the presentation, except for the clarity of the words and their size, but also there seems to be to full with pictures. Excellent work freond min!
Estel 9/10
Goldie
Seles 8/10 The variety's interesting and the only problem seems to be the text clarity. This is just an opinion, but the graphic could probably use more contrast or it looks really ghostly and poorly defined.

[Goldmoon]

What a wonderful banner Caewyn..I love the colors, layout and the sun setting in the back ground. Beautiful, a real good one. I'd have to say a 10
Now Aisil, a truly wonderful banner, although it's a good one i'd like to see more of it. I'll say an 8 Truly great work and i hope to see more come forward.T

[Caewýn Alquasilme]

Goldie, why don't u edit ur scores into Erk's post.

I assume I'm not a judge anymore?*g*

[Seles]

Here's mine! I had to tone down the background image a bit to cater to the text... Meh, I liked the vibrance! It's completely resizable but I don't think I can edit the text... Saved the file accidentally at the wrong stage.

[Lau]

OH! Seles very nice!

Good job everyone else too!

[Aisil Alquasilme]

oooh, I love that one!! ;D

[_]

I know I'm a little late on this competition... but I cannot refuse a challenge when I'm faced with one. I've been on a role with making banners at the moment... I tried to keep them light and easy on the eyes. I made one of each kingdom that I thought would be good to use... Rivendell and Gondor (I wasn't able to get a good picture of Rohan in time). If anybody minds I'd like critical comments on these banners please. (Yet again these were done at 11pm) (Credits: Link to original images: www.hollywoodjesus.com/movie/lotr_fellowship/68.jpg www.the-reel-mccoy.com/movies/2003/images/ReturnOfTheKing_Gondor.jpg ) But anywho here are my banners:

and

Sorry about how badly the banners turned out... I spent less than 10 minutes on them.